17 December 2017
Bob Lyddon

Bob Lyddon

Bob Lyddon - Lyddon Consulting Services

13Posts 63,336Views 34Comments
Fintech innovation and startups

Fintech innovation and startups

Disruption, destruction, harmony and creation; Fintech’s new frontier – a place to discuss the cutting edge of innovation.

How to torpedo the Catalonian economy, in about 25 minutes

28 October 2017  |  4847 views  |  1

Catalonia is not a part of the SEPA Area; it has no central bank and so it has no Eurosystem member.

Its financial infrastructure is, however, SEPA-compliant, meaning domestic and cross-border high-value payments are made and received through TARGET2, domestic low-value through Iberpay, and cross-border low-value through Iberpay and EBA STEP2.

Bank branches are identified through BICs, and accounts through IBANs. Getting a payment to and from bank accounts is enabled by routing tables, which sit behind all of TARGET, Iberpay and EBA STEP2. The entry points are the main offices of the Spanish banks, and settlement occurs over the TARGET2 accounts of the Spanish banks at Banca d’Espana, Spain’s Eurosystem member.

In other words it is all controlled from Madrid, via the main offices of the Spanish banks or by the Banca d’Espana.

Under SEPA rules all accounts in Catalonia must be “reachable”, and this “reachability” is determined through the IBANs and BICs, and the routing tables behind them.

All that Madid has to do is to take down from the routing tables the BICs of every bank branch in Catalonia, and then every bank account held in those branches – identified by an IBAN – becomes unreachable for electronic euro payments:

  • Payments with both endpoints in Catalonia;
  • Payments with one endpoint in Catalonia and the other elsewhere in Spain;
  • Payments with one endpoint in Catalonia and the other elsewhere in the EU.

Merchants would not be able to receive proceeds of card sales on Mastercard, Visa and any other networks because, even if the acquirer would accept the transaction, the card issuer would not be able to settle proceeds to a bank account in Catalonia.

Banca d’Espana, as Spain’s Eurosystem member, is the distributor of Euro banknotes. They might not be able to restrict Spanish banks filling their ATM networks in Catalonia with notes trucked in, but any independent owners of ATM estates in Catalonia could be starved, as well as regional Catalonian banks. Banknotes in circulation already would continue to circulate, but begin with usage to fail to be of ATM quality.

Catalonia cannot protest this in any court because it is not a recognised legal person.

Catalonia is thus cut off from all the main types of payment transaction, and from the results in terms of domestic and cross-border trade, international travel connections and tourism.

These are the penalties of a UDI in a modern networked society, particularly in the Eurozone. It beggars belief that the Catalan government are so ignorant of the basics of money flows as to not realise that their actions severely risk the ability of Catalan citizens to put bread on the table.

Perhaps they will come up with a Cata-crypto-currency into which citizens would have to convert their euro: good luck with that.

  

 

TagsPaymentsFinancial inclusion

Comments: (2)

Dirk Kinvig
Dirk Kinvig - Finextra - London | 30 October, 2017, 08:49

Well, according to hacked, the Catalonians are considering their own cryptcurrency....though take the article with a massive pinch of salt as the article also states that, " Ethereum founder Vitalik Buterin has already advised the Catalans about how to implement the system". A claim which Buterin has already dismissed.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Bob Lyddon
Bob Lyddon - Lyddon Consulting Services - Thames Ditton | 30 October, 2017, 10:45

Hi Dirk - thanks: why am I not surprised about that news? It's a knee-jerk, easy answer, a good headline. Yanis Varoufakis proposed this, I believe, to enable Greece to manufacture money in parallel to having to comply with the Troika's austerity diktats, so that Greece could comply and bypass simultaneously. Didn't Ethereum sign something big with JPMorgan at SIBOS, and isn't JPMorgan is a prime dealer in Spanish government securities? Mr Buterin, if he had been asked by the Catalans, may already have taken a call from 270 Park Avenue NY to ask him which side of his 'pan' is 'mantequilla'd'.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Bob

UK NPA Blueprint rubber-stamped

08 December 2017  |  3771 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsPaymentsTransaction bankingGroupTransaction Banking

The UK Autumn 2017 Budget - the small print

23 November 2017  |  2458 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0

Forget Bermuda & look at the 'legal' tax avoidance within the EU

06 November 2017  |  5363 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsTransaction bankingBrexit

Bob's profile

job title Consultant
location Thames Ditton
member since 2008
Summary profile See full profile »
Consultant in payments, electronic banking, banking regulation and international banking services.

Bob's expertise

Member since 2007
3 posts34 comments
What Bob reads

Who's commenting on Bob's posts

Dirk Kinvig