22 March 2018
Paul Penrose


Paul Penrose - Finextra

307Posts 1,356,831Views 246Comments


EBAday is the annual event for European payments professionals organised by Finextra and the Euro Banking Association. This community has been created to deliver a forum for EBA delegates to exchange views on instant payments, open banking and new developments in payments processing and technology.

Time to scrap cash?

20 May 2009  |  3987 views  |  2

With the spectre of negative interest rates hoving into view, is it time to rethink the value of cash as a medium of exchange?

Failure to do so will lead inevitably to currency hoarding as savers turn their assets into cash to avoid the deflationary effects of a move to negative interest charges.

In his maverecon blog at the FT, Wiliam Buiter, a former member of the Bank of England's monetary policy committee, looks at the options available to hide-bound central banks, including abolition of currency, taxing currency by physically time-stamping it, or unbundling it from the unit of account.

He concludes: "Taxing currency may be awkward and intrusive, but abolishing currency is not just easy (just do it) but also has considerable advantages as a blow against criminality and terrorism.  Unbundling currency and numéraire is something that can be done over the weekend. I really don’t understand why central banks are not aggressively pursuing options for removing the zero lower bound.  It is that they love the seigniorage so much?"

TagsPaymentsRetail banking

Comments: (2)

Keith Richbell
Keith Richbell - eftpos Payments Australia Ltd. (ePAL) - Sydney | 20 May, 2009, 23:46

You bet they love the seigniorage income that much! Mind you, unless we also see the abolishion of sex, drugs and taxation, I imagine your average citizen would be against killing off physical banknotes too. Have you ever seen the results of tests to investigate banknote contamination by cocaine? To put it into context, last week police in Sydney made random stops of car drivers coming into the city to test them for drugs. 9% tested positive.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 21 May, 2009, 16:01

Fundamentally cash is just a medium of exchange and people will start using shells or meteorites if gold is suddenly or mysteriously devalued (very possible) and cash is withdrawn (less likely). Plenty of diamonds available and although they can be manufactured, there is little seignorage in making them at current prices.

Possibly a more realistic goal might be to get a slightly better taxation handle on the electronic money possibilities. The issues of identity and taxation are likely to be more solvable and fruitful for cash strapped governments.

Without taking the incentive out of holding cash, it won't go away, and in many cases cash or cash related events are the incentive for people to work. It would be a vary dangerous move to undermine cash in order to encourage electronic money, at a time when trust is so badly shaken.

As the governments were far behind the real events with the financial crisis, they are likely to be far behind future sentiment events. There will be some level of 'sentimentality' about cash.

The only way cash will be supplanted is by a more convenient, safe and reliable alternative. It would be presumptuous to describe anything extant thus.

The taxation issue is an obvious case of backward thinking anyway - we should be taxed purely on consumption, not effort. Therin lays the solution to global warming, government's needs and perhaps economic and political stability.



Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Paul

ANZ and Visa lose the plot

30 June 2011  |  6758 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsMobile & onlineRetail banking

Don't give up the day job...ever

20 May 2010  |  5995 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionWholesale bankingGroupWhatever...

Now we are ten

19 April 2010  |  6360 views  |  3 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRetail bankingWholesale banking

Finextra's Best of the Web

05 March 2010  |  5876 views  |  1 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRetail bankingWholesale banking

The ATM was the last great financial innovation

25 February 2010  |  10016 views  |  8 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRetail bankingWholesale bankingGroupFinance 2.0

Paul's profile

job title Head of Research
location London
member since 2007
Summary profile See full profile »
I'm responsible for editorial content and quality control across the full range of Finextra media.

Paul's expertise

Member since 2006
307 posts246 comments

Who's commenting on Paul's posts