25 July 2016
Find out more

European Central Bank warns of virtual currency risks

30 October 2012  |  11840 views  |  6 Check close up

The growth of virtual currency schemes such as Bitcoin and Second Life's Linden Dollars, could have a negative reputational impact on central banks due to their inherent instability, warns the European Central Bank.

In a preliminary impact assessment of the proliferation of virtual currency schemes, the ECB notes that while most such schemes are too small to jeopardise price or financial stability, they do represent a challenge to public authorities due to the legal uncertainty surrounding their status and their adoption by criminals and money launderers.

Lack of overarching regulation is a key theme picked up by the ECB, which expresses concern about the level of credit, liquidity, operational and legal risks imposed upon users.

The ECB argues that schemes like Bitcoin and Linden Dollars "do indeed fall within central banke' responsibility" as a result of characteristics shared with payment systems.

In particular, the ECB is worried that the growth of such schemes could have a negative impact on the reputation of central banks.

"In the event that an incident attracts press coverage...the public may perceive the incident as being caused, in part, by a central bank not doing its job properly<" states the report.

The ECB recommends that regulators pay closer attention to ongoing developments in technology innovation and currency creation to anticipate future threats.

"Owing to the small size of virtual currency schemes, these risks do not affect anyone other than users of the schemes," the report concludes. "This assessment could change if usage increases significantly, for example if it were boosted by innovations which are currently being developed or offered. As a consequence, it is recommended that developments are regularly examined in order to reassess the risks."

Read the full report:» Download the document now 1.9 mb (PDF File)

Comments: (6)

Joss Wilbraham
Joss Wilbraham - WMG Consultants Ltd. - Oxford | 30 October, 2012, 13:06

This is a bit rich coming from the ECB! Sure there are risks associated with these new, virtual currencies but in aggregate, no more risk than from the multitude of Central Banks that seem intent on destroying the real value of the world's main currencies through a stealth tax otherwise known as inflation. The alternatives can't arrive quick enough! Let's just hope that that the same Central Banks don't regulate them out of existence in order to protect their own money printing schemes.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 30 October, 2012, 13:34

As long as they are regulated as CBs and there is control of the currency that fits within the existing economic mechanism i can no problem However the virtual nature of this curency could encourage the very worst parts of society that would use it for criminal ends

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 30 October, 2012, 17:06

At Javelin we've published two research reports on virtual currencies, and the surprisingly sparse attention they recieved shows that the payments and banking industry is failing to look far enough ahead. Our conclusion from research of consumers combined with review of the industry triad of gaming, banking and payments found that virtual currency is surprisingly advanced for something that has escaped the spotlight. Because some virtual currencies can be converted to traditional currency right now, this represents an unregulated area with potential significant mainstream impact. Kudos to The European Central Bank for focusing on it, and here's hoping others follow their lead. 

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Frank Mastrangelo
Frank Mastrangelo - The Bancorp, Inc. - Wilmington, DE | 30 October, 2012, 17:51

Gary - are you suggesting that currency regulated CBs is not utlized for criminal ends?

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 31 October, 2012, 09:08

I think there's a great danger that increased centralised oversight of these virtual currencies actually increases economic exposure by legitimising them - and the fact that these are decentralised currencies created by proprietary systems mean that there is a general (and well placed) consumer distrust of these products . As soon as they start being legitimised as regulated products, a more generalised uptake is encouraged over the risk aware niche markets which currently use them. If this happens, then the fallout of any serious currency failure or breach will be much larger, and the impact will be felt more heavily by those who do not understand the instruments.

There is a larger problem on the regulation of currencies which have no geographical base, but the main stumbling block here is the technological stability of the currency, not really it’s geographic regulation or its portability.

 

1 thumb up! 1 thumb up! (Log in to thumb up)
Ketharaman Swaminathan
Ketharaman Swaminathan - GTM360 Marketing Solutions - Pune | 01 November, 2012, 10:02

My hitherto favorable views about virtual currency recently underwent a 180-degree turnaround when I switched on my B&N Nook Color a couple of days ago and found that several eBooks suddenly opened up to blank screens. In this case, a little bit of Googling followed by a hard reset solved the problem. I shudder to think what'd happen if I'm struck with a similar problem with my virtual currency. To recover some of my lost money, I'd have to first go bankrupt (equivalent of losing all content after a "hard reset") under the hope that all my money comes back. I don't know how many people will feel comfortable fooling around so much with money - certainly, I won't. Therefore, I tend to agree with @FinextraM's point about "technological stability" being a major stumbling block for the mainstream adoption of virtual currency. Before someone jumps in to point out that my entire bank balance is held by my bank electronically, it might be virtual for the bank but, as far the relationship between me and my bank is concerned, it's real money. The same is not true when I hold my money as virtual currency myself.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Hacked Bitcoin exchange Bitfloor reopens

Hacked Bitcoin exchange Bitfloor reopens

28 September 2012  |  6034 views  |  0 comments
Bitfloor exchange shuts down after $250,000 heist

Bitfloor exchange shuts down after $250,000 heist

05 September 2012  |  5210 views  |  0 comments
US State Representative adopts Bitcoin donation system

US State Representative adopts Bitcoin donation system

04 September 2012  |  12198 views  |  2 comments | 1 tweets
BitInstant confirms Bitcoin card plans

BitInstant confirms Bitcoin card plans

23 August 2012  |  7893 views  |  0 comments
Users sue Bitcoin exchange over $460k in missing funds

Users sue Bitcoin exchange over $460k in missing funds

13 August 2012  |  7015 views  |  0 comments
Bitcoin exchange loses $90,000 in virtual currency hack

Bitcoin exchange loses $90,000 in virtual currency hack

14 May 2012  |  8808 views  |  0 comments
Google scrapped plans for virtual currency over regulatory concerns

Google scrapped plans for virtual currency over regulatory concerns

01 March 2012  |  12332 views  |  2 comments
Paxum ditches Bitcoin as Tradehill exchange shuts down

Paxum ditches Bitcoin as Tradehill exchange shuts down

20 February 2012  |  9242 views  |  0 comments
American Express files virtual currency patent

American Express files virtual currency patent

01 November 2011  |  15330 views  |  1 comments
Bitcoin POS system developed

Bitcoin POS system developed

21 October 2011  |  12388 views  |  0 comments
Amex buys virtual currency firm Sometrics

Amex buys virtual currency firm Sometrics

21 September 2011  |  7623 views  |  0 comments
Exchange lets users pay cash for Bitcoin at bank branches

Exchange lets users pay cash for Bitcoin at bank branches

22 August 2011  |  12364 views  |  0 comments
Bitcoin value crashes after exchange compromised

Bitcoin value crashes after exchange compromised

20 June 2011  |  18734 views  |  0 comments
US senators voice fears over Bitcoin link to online drugs market

US senators voice fears over Bitcoin link to online drugs market

09 June 2011  |  7543 views  |  0 comments
Virtual currency used for commodity trade

Virtual currency used for commodity trade

15 April 2011  |  15154 views  |  0 comments | 1 tweets
China bans use of virtual cash for trade in the wider economy

China bans use of virtual cash for trade in the wider economy

30 June 2009  |  7293 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Visit www.abe-eba.euVisit VocaLink.comVisit capgemini.com

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
MasterCard agrees £700m VocaLink acquisitionMasterCard agrees £700m VocaLink acqu...
8865 views 14 comments | 32 tweets | 37 linkedin
satelliteContactless Bitcoin startup Plutus Tap &am...
8664 views comments | 8 tweets | 3 linkedin
hands typing furiouslyWhat Every FinTech CEO Should Know About R...
8439 views 0 | 15 tweets | 8 linkedin
hands typing furiouslyBanking on IoT: Security in the Internet o...
8153 views 3 | 20 tweets | 7 linkedin
Santander doubles down on fintech fundSantander doubles down on fintech fund
7780 views comments | 22 tweets | 28 linkedin

Featured job


Brussels (Belgium) or Paris (France)

Find your next job