22 August 2017
Find out more

Industry clamour over MiFID II proposals grows louder

03 February 2011  |  11408 views  |  0 mifid

The Futures and Options Association has added its voice to the growing industry clamour over 'needlessly oppressive' pending market reform proposals from the European Commission.

The FOA has spelled out its concerns in a response to a consultation document issued by Brussels in October that tabled a wide set of reforms to the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive, dubbed MiFID II.

As well as reigning in dark pools and high frequency trading activities, the MiFID review document also called for a ban on trading in more 'speculative' commodities and demanded more transparency in over-the-counter trading and a switch to exchange-based systems and a new category of 'Organised Trading Facilities'.

The FOA warns that the weight of additional obligations and requirements placed upon firms by the reform process could be duplicative and unnecessary and that the impact on a "thinly-staffed" European Securities Markets Authority (ESMA) will be intense.

Among the specific areas within the review, FOA suggests that the role of speculators in commodity markets is critically important and excessive speculation should be dealt with through position management rather than position limits. It also calls for commercial purpose physical forward and spot transactions to remain outside the MiFID scope.

The use of product bans, "will have severe implications for the function of markets" warns the lobby group "and may even exacerbate risk to the financial system".

FOA chief executive Anthony Belchambers comments: "A number of the requirements in the review are needlessly oppressive, particularly the proposed limits on execution-only business and bilateral execution. Additionally, the swathe of costly disclosure obligations is more likely to confuse than inform customers."

Similar objections have been aired by the International Capital Markets Association in a separate submission, which urges the Commission to "adequately consider the full implications of the proposals set out in the paper rather than trying to rush the consultation process, which could result in costly mistakes arising from unintended consequences".

In particular, Icma has called on Brussels to exclude the money markets from the broad review and to resist the urge to "future-proof" the Directive.

"We would strongly warn against trying to make MiFID future-proof if doing so results in the Directive becoming unworkable in practice or imposing such significant regulatory burdens that the barriers to entry become prohibitive for all but the largest firms/participants."

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

EC publishes MiFID II consultation

EC publishes MiFID II consultation

08 December 2010  |  12444 views  |  0 comments
MiFID II to tackle high-frequency trading

MiFID II to tackle high-frequency trading

03 December 2010  |  12335 views  |  0 comments
Nyse Technologies to develop EU consolidated tape

Nyse Technologies to develop EU consolidated tape

22 November 2010  |  11184 views  |  3 comments
EC bids to tame 'wild west territory' of OTC derivatives and short selling

EC bids to tame 'wild west territory' of OTC derivatives and short selling

15 September 2010  |  8463 views  |  0 comments
CESR signals MiFID overhaul

CESR signals MiFID overhaul

29 July 2010  |  12998 views  |  0 comments
Post-MiFID fragmentation inviting more market abuse - Avenues

Post-MiFID fragmentation inviting more market abuse - Avenues

16 March 2010  |  9423 views  |  2 comments
Major dealers outline next steps in OTC clean-up

Major dealers outline next steps in OTC clean-up

03 March 2010  |  10112 views  |  0 comments
Regulators fast-track global review of OTC derivatives clearing

Regulators fast-track global review of OTC derivatives clearing

02 February 2010  |  8616 views  |  0 comments
EU's MiFID review to look at dark pools

EU's MiFID review to look at dark pools

21 September 2009  |  11695 views  |  0 comments
Europe braces for MiFID II as regulators assess market impact

Europe braces for MiFID II as regulators assess market impact

10 June 2009  |  11493 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
visit www.vasco.comvisit www.niceactimize.comdownload the paper now

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Mobile contactless spending accelerating in UKMobile contactless spending accelerating i...
12579 views comments | 26 tweets | 23 linkedin
Barclays pairs banking data with third party apps for SmartBusiness DashboardBarclays pairs banking data with third par...
11161 views comments | 22 tweets | 34 linkedin
hands typing furiouslyWhy Is Risk Analytics Important?
10332 views 0 | 6 tweets | 1 linkedin
RBS to bring Silicon Valley to EdinburghRBS to bring Silicon Valley to Edinburgh
10295 views comments | 10 tweets | 8 linkedin
Australia regulates digital currenciesAustralia regulates digital currencies
10243 views comments | 21 tweets | 34 linkedin

Featured job

Competitive
London, UK (or flexible)

Find your next job