19 July 2018
Visit www.avoka.com

Anonymous FX market model mooted at Sibos

04 October 2007  |  7805 views  |  0 Anonymous FX market model mooted at Sibos

The extent of demand for anonymous, electronic trading in the FX market was debated during a lively panel discussion on e-FX at the Sibos event in Boston.

Whereas Mark Robson, chief executive of FX MarketSpace - the centrally-cleared platform developed by Reuters and the Chicago Mercantile Exchange - argued that the demand for anonymous trading was a key motivation for setting up the company, his fellow panelists were less convinced.

"The reason we set up FX MarketSpace was because the market was not happy with the level of anonymity," said Robson. "They don't want people backward engineering their algorithms. In our model there is only one participant seeing your trade."

Anonymous trading is prevalent in many other asset classes where liquidity is less pronounced than in FX and where participants are keen to lessen the market impact of their trades. But, according to Phillip Brittan, global business manager and head of FX at Bloomberg, anonymity is less important in FX.

"The FX market is so deep that access to liquidity is not a problem and it is very difficult to have an impact on the market. It is so distributed and overwhelmingly driven by relationships between liquidity providers and traders, often on a one-one basis."

Brittan referred to the various attempts that have been made to develop an exchange-based model for FX but concluded that they have all failed to attract users.

His views were supported by Simon Wilson-Taylor, executive vice president and head of Global Link at State Street Global Markets, who said that the preposition of FX Marketspace was perhaps indicative of the flaws in asking the market what it wants. "Sometimes the whole world can be wrong," said Wilson-Taylor, echoing the words of an earlier Sibos speaker, internet guru Nicholas Negroponte.

"Many of today's FX participants have come from other asset classes such as equities. Now many of them are learning that they need to develop relationships with their counterparties and are realizing that they can do their large trades quietly through their trusted counterparties."

According to the final panelist, Sandie O'Connor, global head of securities lending & execution products, JPMorgan Securities Services, even for those few FX traders that felt anonymity was important, the question really came down to whether FX traders would want an exchange providing the anonymity or a trusted counterparty such as a prime broker with whom a long-term and trusted relationship had been established.

After a quick show of hands, the views of the audience showed an overwhelming preference for anonymous FX trading. A clearly relieved Mark Robson welcomed the vote. "That's democracy in action," he said.

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Buy-side boosts FX trading volumes

Buy-side boosts FX trading volumes

11 April 2007  |  6147 views  |  0 comments
FXMarketSpace clears regulatory hurdle; finishes first phase customer tests

FXMarketSpace clears regulatory hurdle; finishes first phase customer tests

13 February 2007  |  5094 views  |  0 comments
E-FX trading volumes set to grow

E-FX trading volumes set to grow

10 October 2006  |  6659 views  |  0 comments
FXMarketSpace adds to top team

FXMarketSpace adds to top team

13 September 2006  |  5583 views  |  0 comments
Major FX players sign up to FXMarketSpace

Major FX players sign up to FXMarketSpace

17 July 2006  |  9376 views  |  0 comments
Reuters and CME to launch global FX marketplace

Reuters and CME to launch global FX marketplace

04 May 2006  |  12432 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Visit http://go.jumio.com/finextraAdVisit info.nice.comVisit https://secure.vasco.com

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Calmejane quits Lloyds Bank to join SocGenCalmejane quits Lloyds Bank to join SocGen
11799 views comments | 5 tweets | 7 linkedin
Metro Bank opens developer portalMetro Bank opens developer portal
10035 views comments | 5 tweets | 14 linkedin
Anything Visa can do...Mastercard takes time outAnything Visa can do...Mastercard takes ti...
9692 views comments | 6 tweets | 15 linkedin
Mastercard enlists Worldpay to push Vocalink's Pay by Bank appMastercard enlists Worldpay to push Vocali...
9234 views 19 comments | 14 tweets | 30 linkedin
Hong Kong plans September go-live for blockchain-based trade financeHong Kong plans September go-live for bloc...
9006 views comments | 9 tweets | 17 linkedin

Featured job

Basic c Euro 120K, Variable Euro 120K - full ben...
Paris prefered London possible

Find your next job