16 August 2017
Find out more

Industry groups hit out at FSA best execution proposals

17 July 2006  |  7185 views  |  0 mifid

Leading industry lobby groups have criticised proposals from the Financial Services Authority for the use of price benchmarks to demonstrate best execution in OTC and fixed income markets.

The International Capital Market Association (Icma), the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (Isda) and The Bond Market Association (TBMA), argue that there are no robust benchmarks for most fixed income products, and that benchmarking is incompatible with OTC derivatives and structured products.

The industry groups have raised their concerns in response to an FSA discussion paper released two months ago on the possible extension of MiFID-style best execution requirements to the bond markets.

The Associations argue that the proposals on benchmarking contradict recent statements by the FSA calling for flexibility in the regulation of fixed income markets.

They warn that the imposition of benchmarking would be expensive to implement in practice and could potentially lead to withdrawal of liquidity.

Instead, they call for a principles-based approach based on “intelligent copy-out” of the MiFID provisions on best execution, supplemented by MiFID Connect industry guidance.

This, they maintain, would recognise that "execution quality depends on other factors in addition to price, that the relative importance of these factors varies between clients, and that firms have some flexibility in determining their order execution policy".

They further suggest the FSA adopt a practical interpretation of what constitutes the execution of a client order in dealer markets, since this determines when the best execution obligation and therefore the benchmark proposal may apply.

Bertrand Huet, European legal and regulatory counsel, TBMA, says: "The FSA needs to recognise that there is no such thing as continuously executable price available from a predominant source of liquidity in dealer markets. Its approach needs to be mindful of current market structure, promote the competitiveness of EU financial markets and ensure that information remains available to wholesale and retail investors."

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

FSA cautions against extending MiFID to bond markets

FSA cautions against extending MiFID to bond markets

05 July 2006  |  10002 views  |  0 comments
FSA subscribes to Markit credit data

FSA subscribes to Markit credit data

03 July 2006  |  6028 views  |  0 comments
McCreevy urges firms to prepare for MiFID

McCreevy urges firms to prepare for MiFID

27 June 2006  |  7085 views  |  0 comments
European Commission to probe transparency risks in non-cash markets

European Commission to probe transparency risks in non-cash markets

12 June 2006  |  5157 views  |  0 comments
Financial firms unprepared for MiFID - study

Financial firms unprepared for MiFID - study

10 April 2006  |  7585 views  |  0 comments
European Commission tables MiFID proposals

European Commission tables MiFID proposals

06 February 2006  |  9602 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
visit www.worldpaymentsreport.comvisit www.niceactimize.comvisit www.dorsum.eu

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
hands typing furiouslyBI and Analytics - A New Perspective
10913 views 0 | 2 tweets | 12 linkedin
Coinbase raises $100mCoinbase raises $100m
9990 views comments | 14 tweets | 14 linkedin
DBS Bank launches online car selling marketplaceDBS Bank launches online car selling marke...
9371 views comments | 13 tweets | 11 linkedin
China preps central clearing house for mobile payments providersChina preps central clearing house for mob...
9066 views comments | 8 tweets | 15 linkedin
HSBC automates documentary trade processing with IBMHSBC automates documentary trade processin...
8207 views comments | 6 tweets | 21 linkedin

Featured job

Competitive base and bonus, plus benefits
London, UK

Find your next job