/cryptocurrency

News and resources on digital currencies, crypto assets and crypto exchanges worldwide.
ECB officials liken crypto regulation to providing new clothes for a 'naked emperor'

ECB officials liken crypto regulation to providing new clothes for a 'naked emperor'

Senior payments experts at the European Central Bank have billed the SEC's approval of spot exchange-traded funds (ETF) for bitcoin as an example of the 'naked emperors new clothes', legitimising a currency whose fair value as an asset is effectively zero.

In a blog post published by the European Central Bank, Ulrich Bindseil, director general of market infrastructure and payments and Jürgen Schaaf, an advisor to the central bank, say that for bitcoin lobbyists the formal approval by the SEC confirms that Bitcoin investments are safe and the preceding rally is proof of an unstoppable triumph.

In the mid-2010s, the hope that bitcoin's value would inevitably rise to ever new heights began to dominate the narrative. But bitcoin is neither suitable as an investment or even as a real-world means of payments, the blog argues.

Bindseil and Schaff believe that lower interest rates and the SEC green light have opened the floodgates to Wall Street for bitcoin, promising large inflows of funds, "the only effective fuel in a speculative bubble".

"While in the short run the inflowing money can have a large impact on prices irrespective of fundamentals, prices will eventually return to their fundamental values in the long run," states the post. "And without any cash flow or other returns, the fair value of an asset is zero. Detached from economic fundamentals every price is equally (im)plausible - a fantastic condition for snake oil salesmen."

In a previous blog post in November last year, Bindseil and Schaaf, urged lawmakers to shy away from regulatory measures, pointing out that big bitcoin investors have the strongest incentives to keep the euphoria going and have hired armies of lobbyists to push their case with lawmakers and regulators.

In their latest post on the issue, the authors state: "While the current rally is fuelled by temporary factors, there are three structural reasons that may explain its seeming resilience: the ongoing manipulation of the 'price' in an unregulated market without oversight and without fair value, the growing demand for the 'currency of crime', and shortcomings in the authorities’ judgments and measures."

They argue that both the SEC's approval of bitcoin ETFs and the EU's Markets in Crypto Assets Regulation, have only served to convince less informed outsiders that bitcoin is a sound and safe investment, without taking any effective steps to address Bitcoin's outsized energy consumption and the financing of terrorism and crimes like money laundering and ransomware.

In conclusion, they argue: "Bitcoin’s price level is not an indicator of its sustainability. There are no economic fundamental data, there is no fair value from which serious forecasts can be derived. There is no 'proof of price' in a speculative bubble. Instead, a reflation of the speculative bubble shows the effectiveness of the Bitcoin lobby. The 'market' capitalisation quantifies the overall social damage that will occur when the house of cards collapses."

Comments: (4)

A Finextra member
A Finextra member 22 February, 2024, 13:101 like 1 like The trouble with these comments is that they are as colored and influenced by an institution which has every interest in seeing crypto not used. Because their eyes are set on retail CBDC’s, which have many disadvantages as well. It is time we have a mature discussion and not a shouting match with poor arguments from on the one hand bitcoin haters and the other hand bitcoin evangelists. The user cases for more generally crypto and the underlying technologies with for example smart contracts enabling all kinds of digital assets companies and projects are undeniably there. Large banks and other institutions are working with them already. Europe’s regulation and FED’s first moves are good and necessary steps to providing consumer protection and more while CBDC’s provide no real additional benefits.
A Finextra member
A Finextra member 22 February, 2024, 17:18Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 likes As an additional comment: believe many tax paying citizens would be delighted if they would not have to pay taxes on their bitcoin holdings as these are worth zero according to the ECB. Please let all of the relevant tax authorities in Europe know!
Raynaldo Martine
Raynaldo Martine - WCTH - Oceanside 23 February, 2024, 03:24Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 likes

Bitcoin is only "paving the way" for the "utility coins" which have actual purposes like speeding up, and reducing the cost of cross border payments; tokenization of assets/value; and for instantaneous tracking of shipments that will have smart contracts working as bills of lading, immediate payment, as well as pre-authorized customs paperwork in digital form. Blockchains like HBAR, XRP, and especially XDC (for trade finance) are going to revolutionize the movement of value. Bitcoin will never be anything more than a "storage of value", and I believe its days are numbered as it is an energy hog. These are the block chains mentioned above are all three carbon negative, and work in under three seconds.

Raynaldo Martine
Raynaldo Martine - WCTH - Oceanside 23 February, 2024, 03:27Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 likes

very sorry, the last line should have read "These other block chains mentioned above are all three carbon negative, and work in under three seconds.Very sorry, the last line should have read "

Trending