24 February 2018
visit www.nextgenbanking.co.uk/

CLS hits back at critics

05 October 2007  |  9055 views  |  0 foreign exchange rates on screen

Bank-backed settlement body Continuous Linked Settlement (CLS) has responded to industry concerns over the spiraling costs of settling FX trades, insisting that it intends to reduce transaction costs by roughly half as volumes rise.

CLS also intends to reconsider its current position on bilateral netting, where payments between two banks are netted off on a daily basis, a practice currently prohibited within the CLS multilateral operating model.

Massive growth in FX transaction volumes, fuelled by the emergence of high-frequency algorithmic trading had sparked fears that the old pricing structure used by CLS would prove crippling for firms that had increased their trading volumes by as much as tenfold and has led to them seeking alternative methods of settlement.

A white paper released by FX vendor Wall Street Systems states that a number of its FX clients had voiced such fears and were increasingly looking to bilateral netting as a means of settling trades.

The white paper concludes that "banks cannot continue to rely exclusively on CLS for their FX settlement and risk needs" and that many are "already investigating lower cost alternatives to CLS".

"Some CLS shareholders are already using CLS purely to mitigate settlement risk and choosing bilateral netting to produce payment instructions. Other banks will follow suit, which may have an impact on CLS in the future."

The Wall Street Systems' white paper was released on the back of a report issued in July 2007 by the BIS Committee on Payment and Settlement Systems which called for a greater reduction of settlement risk by FX participants, citing that, as of April 2006, only 55% of the total FX settlement obligations had been settled through CLS with 32% still settled through the traditional and highly exposed correspondent banking arrangements.

Rick Schumacher, product manager of Wall Street Systems suggests that a possible reason for the limited adoption rates of CLS is the concern over cost and a perceived lack of benefits of scale, an issue made all the more pressing by the predominance of high-volume algorithmic trading. "When CLS first started, banks were doing 10,000 trades a day. But now that has increased to 150,000 in many instances," says Schumacher.

As regards Wall Street Systems' motive for the white paper, Schumacher insisted that "it was not a dig at CLS" and that it is agnostic in terms of how FX trades are settled. "We are just trying to track the industry issues and provide some suggestions to further the debate."

CLS has responded to the white paper by dismissing the claims over the rising cost of its service insisting that, on the contrary, current costs are expected to decrease by half as transaction volumes rise following the introduction of a sliding scale for pricing.

According to Jonathan Butterfield, executive vice president, marketing and communication at CLS, the average cost of settlement in August was 53p per transaction. Should volumes reach 1 million sides, settlement costs will be no more than 25p, says Butterfield.

As regards bilateral netting, Butterfield adds that a decision was taken in July by CLS members not to adjust the current position which prohibits the practice due to the fact that CLS cannot provide a full audit trail for trades. However Butterfield says that he expects that this decision should and will be revisited in the near future.

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Regulators call for bank action to cut FX settlement risk

Regulators call for bank action to cut FX settlement risk

18 July 2007  |  6809 views  |  0 comments
CLS volumes set to grow

CLS volumes set to grow

24 October 2005  |  7685 views  |  0 comments
Buy-side challenge for CLS as interbank FX markets feel the benefit

Buy-side challenge for CLS as interbank FX markets feel the benefit

26 July 2005  |  9333 views  |  0 comments
CLS volumes forecast to rise

CLS volumes forecast to rise

25 May 2004  |  3917 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Visit http://info.nice.comvisit www.nextgenbanking.co.ukvisit www.swift.com/your-needs/instant-payments

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Ripple makes new connections to emerging marketsRipple makes new connections to emerging m...
11793 views comments | 16 tweets | 10 linkedin
hands typing furiouslySome Interesting Applications Of The Inter...
10326 views 3 | 9 tweets | 1 linkedin
Basel Committee outlines disruptive fintech scenariosBasel Committee outlines disruptive fintec...
8568 views comments | 15 tweets | 26 linkedin
Investment Association sets up fintech accelerator for asset managersInvestment Association sets up fintech acc...
8090 views comments | 19 tweets | 10 linkedin
R3 creates Legal Centre of Excellence for blockchain technolgyR3 creates Legal Centre of Excellence for...
7775 views comments | 10 tweets | 14 linkedin

Featured job

Competitive
Germany, Austria or Switzerland

Find your next job