29 April 2017
Find out more

Centralised clearing for OTC derivatives receives industry support but concerns remain

04 February 2010  |  9343 views  |  0 Digital Abstarct

The majority of financial institutions and corporations around the world agree that moving OTC derivatives trading to a system of centralised clearing would help manage risk but many market participants still harbour serious concerns about the prospect, according to a survey from Greenwich Associates.

Respondents to the survey broadly agree that centralised clearing would be an effective means of managing both counterparty risk at an individual level and market-wide systemic issues.

Around 80% of the 330 survey participants cite counterparty risk mitigation as the primary benefit of centralised clearing, a share that approaches 90% among financials. At a broader level, over half believe a move to centralised clearing would be effective at mitigating systemic risk. The case is most pressing for credit default swaps, say respondents.

However, many raise concerns about the ongoing process of market structure reform and are uncertain about details of the proposals currently being considered. A surprisingly high 47% of respondents say they are either entirely in the dark about centralised clearing plans or less knowledgeable than they would like to be about the details of the proposals.

While there is near unanimity on the risk benefits of OTC centralised clearing, concerns have been raised about its impact on trading volumes. Overall, 42% of respondents do not think the shift would have any effect on the notional trading volumes they execute, while 44% of financial institutions think volumes will increase.

Another potential concern is cost, with half of those questioned predicting that a move to centralised clearing will lead to tighter bid/ask spreads on OTC derivatives. Overall, 47% of survey respondents cite the potential for increased transaction costs on OTC derivatives trades as a significant drawback of centralised clearing and 70% see the potential for increased costs associated with margin requirements as an important negative consequence.

"In general, corporations participating in the study believe costs associated with creating and maintaining the centralised clearing system will ultimately be passed on to customers," says Andrew Awad, consultant, Greenwich Associates.

In addition, approximately three quarters of corporations fear the newly enforced standardisation of contracts required by a shift to centralised clearing will limit flexibility, creating mismatches in positions and disqualifying some trades from hedge accounting.

Finally, when asked which organisations should run central clearinghouses for OTC derivatives, respondents in continental Europe favour Eurex. UK companies and financials prefer LCH.Clearnet, with Eurex and ICE also receiving votes. The preferred provider of North American firms is CME Group.

Earlier this week, global banking and securities regulators revealed they were fast-tracking a review of clearing arrangements for OTC derivatives as part of a far-reaching re-appraisal of existing standards for payments, clearing and settlement systems.

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Regulators fast-track global review of OTC derivatives clearing

Regulators fast-track global review of OTC derivatives clearing

02 February 2010  |  8382 views  |  0 comments
CME Group launches CDS clearing

CME Group launches CDS clearing

16 December 2009  |  6108 views  |  0 comments
BME to take on DTCC with trade repository plan

BME to take on DTCC with trade repository plan

03 November 2009  |  5935 views  |  0 comments
DTCC calls on lawmakers to mandate use of central trade reporting utility

DTCC calls on lawmakers to mandate use of central trade reporting utility

09 October 2009  |  6631 views  |  0 comments
Dealers to accelerate central clearing of OTC trades

Dealers to accelerate central clearing of OTC trades

09 September 2009  |  8642 views  |  0 comments
Nyse Liffe shelves CDS clearing

Nyse Liffe shelves CDS clearing

13 August 2009  |  8058 views  |  0 comments
OTC derivatives gain standards based on FpML

OTC derivatives gain standards based on FpML

29 July 2009  |  6884 views  |  0 comments
ICE Trust sets out plans for buy-side participation in CDS clearing

ICE Trust sets out plans for buy-side participation in CDS clearing

23 July 2009  |  5431 views  |  0 comments
Japan to build CCP for OTC derivatives trading

Japan to build CCP for OTC derivatives trading

22 May 2009  |  8301 views  |  0 comments
CDS clearing plans badly flawed say researchers

CDS clearing plans badly flawed say researchers

22 April 2009  |  11434 views  |  0 comments
Eurex outlines CDS clearing proposal

Eurex outlines CDS clearing proposal

13 October 2008  |  10600 views  |  0 comments
Eurex ventures into OTC derivatives clearing

Eurex ventures into OTC derivatives clearing

23 July 2008  |  7520 views  |  0 comments
Liffe eyes over-the-counter CDS market

Liffe eyes over-the-counter CDS market

07 July 2008  |  9798 views  |  0 comments
Credit derivatives clearing facility to launch in Q3

Credit derivatives clearing facility to launch in Q3

29 May 2008  |  8305 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Visit capgemini.comvisit vasco.com/news/PSD2-compliant-solutionsvisit dh.com

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Six global banks join Swift DLT trialsSix global banks join Swift DLT trials
7683 views comments | 15 tweets | 36 linkedin
BBVA steps up fintech acquisition strategy with purchase of OpenpayBBVA steps up fintech acquisition strategy...
6935 views comments | 17 tweets | 16 linkedin
Token raises $15.7 million as PSD2 approachesToken raises $15.7 million as PSD2 approac...
5914 views comments | 20 tweets | 20 linkedin
Should central banks open up payment and settlement systems to non-banks?Should central banks open up payment and s...
5913 views comments | 22 tweets | 21 linkedin
hands typing furiouslyMobile Technology, Its Importance, Present...
5648 views 0 | 2 tweets | 1 linkedin

Featured job

to 120K base, £300K ote, stock options
London, UK

Find your next job