25 October 2016
Find out more

US payments system failing to meet the needs of the digital economy

04 April 2012  |  11136 views  |  3 Washington Capitol hill

The Federal Reserve and US Congress urgently need to plug a public policy vacuum if the national payment infrastructure is to keep up with changes in the digital economy, according to a former senior Fed executive.

In a paper delivered late last week to a payments summit hosted by the Kansas City Fed, Bruce Summers - a career official with the Federal Reserve until his retirement in 2007 - lamented the lack of public interest governance in the US payments industry.

Taking the failure of the US to develop a mechanism for immediate funds transfer (IFT), such as the UK's Faster Payments scheme, as a key theme, Summers pointed out that neither the Federal Reserve Board nor prominent private sector organisations have either "the interest or the ability" to lead payment system development into the digital age.

"The idea that money in transit is digital information which can be processed immediately has not been readily accepted by the banking industry," he says. "Most bank-sponsored payment schemes depend on clearing and settlement systems that are designed around batch processing and delayed settlement, and these clearing and settlement arrangements are being nurtured as opposed to being re-designed around continuous, real-time processing."

With no impetus from the private sector and the Federal Reserve effectively standing on the sidelines, it may be up to Congress lead the way, as it did 35 years ago when it established the National Commission on Electronic Fund Transfers, which has guided US payments systems developments over the past decades.

At the moment, Congress appears more interested in monitoring security issues around mobile payment schemes, whereas it might be better served by adopting a back-to-basics unpicking of the entire national payments infrastructure.

In conclusion, Summers recommends a four-stage action plan, including the clarification of the Fed's role in payments system development; the creation of a new national commission on payment system innovation; the undertaking of a benchmark assessment of implementing national clearing and settlement processes and infrastructure to support immediate completion of digital payments; and the development of a special-purpose bank charter for non-bank providers of specialised payment services.

Read the full paper:» Download the document now 166.8 kb (PDF File)

Comments: (3)

Denis Wicking
Denis Wicking - F C Consultants - Stowmarket | 04 April, 2012, 13:23

The UK Faster Payments system required a push from the Britsh Treasury, plus senior execs within the member banks who faced up to a promise to deliver the promised solution. This was driven to an agressive timetable through their membership of the  UK Payments Council.

Some execs created a positive business case; others saw the opportunity for payment hubs and a general rationalisation of systems; while a third group were doubters to the last but pulled along by the Payments Council commitment. 

The fulfilling of the promise co-incided with the start of the banking industry upheaval, but those execs remained committed and ended up delivering a market leading solution.  

Because of the major costs involved in both the central hub and, more importantly, the changes to member bank systems to get them out of the batch mindset, I cannot see how the challenge in other countries will be taken up without the direction of central government.

Funadmentally , there will be banks who will not see the business benefit of yet another payment system and only see it as another cost of being regulated.

1 thumb up! 1 thumb up! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 05 April, 2012, 12:36

Very interesting paper .Just goes to show that we always think the grass is geaner on the other side.I would refer those interested in the UK experience which is held up as a paragon of future thinking to have another read of John Kays article from 2009 " The slow drip of the ‘faster’ payments system".

We all wait and see if the industry succeeds for the second time in gaming the system with the Finance Services Bill going through the Lords next month.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Ketharaman Swaminathan
Ketharaman Swaminathan - GTM360 Marketing Solutions - Pune | 05 April, 2012, 19:26

While the UK experience might not be a paragon of futuristic thinking, as we approach the fourth anniversary of the launch of FPS, no one can deny that "it's been there and done that". Whereas we've been hearing about half-measures like Expedited Payments and Same Day ACH in the USA for a long time without any mainstream adoption to show even 3-4 years later. That regulation is necessary to bring about any change to status quo is clear. But, whether it will happen in a lobbying-driven nation like USA is not. 

For registration-wary readers, here's the Google Search result link for the FT article cited by Robin B.

BTW, written in 2009, why does this article, which is full of innuendoes including its title itself, fail to make any mention that FPS was launched a year before its publication?

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Faster Payments volumes surge

Faster Payments volumes surge

19 March 2012  |  9458 views  |  1 comments
EC bids for integrated card, Internet and mobile payments

EC bids for integrated card, Internet and mobile payments

11 January 2012  |  11547 views  |  0 comments
EC to probe barriers to payments integration

EC to probe barriers to payments integration

06 January 2012  |  8835 views  |  4 comments
UK govt plans Payments Council regulation

UK govt plans Payments Council regulation

11 November 2011  |  7811 views  |  0 comments
Nacha proposes Faster Payments-style service for the US

Nacha proposes Faster Payments-style service for the US

30 September 2011  |  7604 views  |  0 comments

Related company news


Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Find out moreFind out moreVisit dh.com

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
Barclays and Citi test blockchain tech for equity swaps processingBarclays and Citi test blockchain tech for...
8780 views comments | 26 tweets | 19 linkedin
Visa treads on Swift's toes with blockchain pilot for high value paymentsVisa treads on Swift's toes with blockchai...
8349 views comments | 33 tweets | 36 linkedin
Monzo raises £4.8mMonzo raises £4.8m
7833 views comments
Visa tells Europe to be ready for 3-D Secure 2.0 by April 2018Visa tells Europe to be ready for 3-D Secu...
7548 views comments | 12 tweets | 26 linkedin
ING takes fintech startup route to UK relaunchING takes fintech startup route to UK rela...
7352 views comments | 29 tweets | 23 linkedin

Featured job

Senior Level Salary plus Car Allowance + Benefits...

Find your next job