09 December 2016
Visit aciworldwide.com

TT dismisses eSpeed patent claims

15 January 2008  |  4561 views  |  0 Digital Abstract

Chicago-based Trading Technologies (TT) has dismissed as "not accurate" claims made by Cantor Fitzgerald unit eSpeed last week that a senior district judge overturned a jury's decision to award it damages for patent infringement.

In October TT claimed victory in the long-running lawsuit after a jury ordered the Cantor Fitzgerald unit to pay it $3.5 million in damages.

But in a statement released last week, eSpeed said that in a 3 January 2008 order, senior district Judge James Moran of the US District Court for the Northern District of Illinois "agreed with eSpeed's motion for a judgement as a matter of law, overturning the jury's October 10 2007 verdict that certain versions of eSpeed's futures-trading software had infringed TT's patents".

ESpeed says the judge ruled that no "reasonable" jury could find that it "wilfully infringed" TT's patented MD Trader technology.

But in its own statement TT disputes the statement, claiming that on the same day in a separate decision the judge denied eSpeed's motion to set aside the jury's verdict of infringement.

In court papers supplied by TT, a minute entry before Judge James Moran, says: "Defendant eSpeed's Combined Motion for Judgement as a Matter of Law that the asserted claims are invalid based on obviousness, anticipation, prior sale, and that the claims have a priority date of June 9, 2000 and have not been infringed [1099] is denied. We agree with defendants that this motion is timely and proper and is not waived. However, we decline to vacate the jury's findings on these issues."

TT says that the judge only overruled the jury's finding of "willfulness" and this is relevant to whether the $3.5 million damages awarded for four to five months of infringement should be increased.

The vendor insists that the jury's finding that eSpeed is liable for patent infringement stands.

The lawsuit is one of more than a dozen filed by TT against brokerages and other vendors over patents related to its MD Trader product, the order-entry screen incorporated in TT's X_Trader software. Unlike eSpeed, the majority have settled with TT out of court.

However in August the US Patent and Trademark Office said it would re-examine and re-evaluate patents held by TT relating to the vendor's order entry system.

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

ESpeed strikes back in TT patent case

ESpeed strikes back in TT patent case

11 January 2008  |  4375 views  |  0 comments
ESpeed gets summary judgment in TT patent case

ESpeed gets summary judgment in TT patent case

29 June 2007  |  4507 views  |  0 comments
Cantor rejects eSpeed bid from Tullett Prebon

Cantor rejects eSpeed bid from Tullett Prebon

18 April 2007  |  8387 views  |  0 comments
Espeed loses OMX patent appeal

Espeed loses OMX patent appeal

27 March 2007  |  4495 views  |  0 comments
Espeed claims victory in TT patent battle

Espeed claims victory in TT patent battle

07 November 2006  |  9195 views  |  0 comments
Man Group settles Trading Technology patent lawsuit

Man Group settles Trading Technology patent lawsuit

01 December 2005  |  8835 views  |  0 comments

Related company news

 

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
Visit capgemini.comFind out moreFind out more

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
China tops world fintech rankingsChina tops world fintech rankings
8313 views comments | 38 tweets | 31 linkedin
Guesswork alone can crack Visa card security - Newcastle UniversityGuesswork alone can crack Visa card securi...
7935 views 12 comments | 15 tweets | 27 linkedin
EBA bends under weight of PSD2 mandatesEBA bends under weight of PSD2 mandates
7923 views comments | 36 tweets | 47 linkedin
Fed Governor sounds warning on alternative credit scoring dataFed Governor sounds warning on alternative...
6748 views comments | 20 tweets | 23 linkedin
PSD2 will transform the payments landscapePSD2 will transform the payments landscape
6716 views comments | 23 tweets | 13 linkedin

Featured job

Find your next job