10 December 2016
Visit aciworldwide.com

Retailers rail about card costs as cash use declines

02 June 2014  |  9207 views  |  7 Shopping mall 2

Contactless cards, online sales and self-service tills are contributing to a steady decline in the use of cash by UK consumers says the British Retail Consortium.

New data reveals that a growing proportion of smaller payments previously made in cash are moving to debit cards, which now account for 50% of retail sales value in 2013, up by 11% over the last five years. Over the same time period there has been a decline in the average debit card transaction value, and in the use of cash by 14%.

However, cash remains the dominant method of payment, with 53% of transactions still made in loose change, although this has declined by three per cent over the last year and 10% over the last five years.

The BRC's Payments Survey 2013 covers 60% or £191 billion in retail sales in 2013.

The figures are broadly in line with recently released data from Halifax Bank, which shows that debit cards are now used in 56% of all transactions and the use of notes and coins on the wane.

For retailers, the switch to plastic is not entirely welcome, with the BRC accusing banks of levying "unjustifiably high" charges for handing card payments. The average cost to a retailer to process a credit or charge card payment is now 40.9 pence, up 18.3% in the last five years. Credit and charge cards account for only nine per cent of transactions but almost half (48.7%) of costs, says the retailer lobby group

At the same time, the cost to process a cash payment is now 1.3 pence and has decreased 38% in the last five years. Cash accounts for 53% of transactions but nine per cent of costs. Debit cards costs have increased by four per cent in the last five years and cost 8.8 pence per transaction. They account for 32% of transactions but 37% of costs.

Comments: (7)

Alexander Peschkoff
Alexander Peschkoff - TEDIPAY - London | 02 June, 2014, 12:08

The cost of transaction is a misleading parameter to focus on. If it were important, all the merchants would still be forcing their customers to pay with cash.

Retailers do spend money on advertising/marketing without blinking, but I bet very few of them know how much it really costs to get new/incremental sale.

The important parameter should be: how can a (new) payment method help me make more money. Is serving one extra customer per hour by accepting mobile payments worth an extra 1% in transaction cost? If such mobile payments also include a loyalty programme, how does that compares to 50% off promotion ("buy 1 get 1 free"), in terms of effectiveness?

 

1 thumb up! 1 thumb up! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 02 June, 2014, 12:24

Credit Cards may only acount for 9% of transactions but nearly half the cost, however the BRC's report shows that credit card volumes are moving in the right direction, with a 12% rise in the average transaction value. This means credit cards are still  being used for high value purchases and are not displacing debit cards at a high cost to the retailer. More fast, payment instruments for low value purchases will reduce cash in circulation and provide retailers with the fast liquidity they need. 

The cost of debit card transactions is not high - it's the credit card fees at a percentage of the value that hurt.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Alexander Peschkoff
Alexander Peschkoff - TEDIPAY - London | 02 June, 2014, 12:31

As for DC txn cost, that depends on use case. Some small merchants are paying as much as 15-25p per txn. For a small-value purchase (say £3.00), that's well over 5%...

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 02 June, 2014, 22:46

I would argue that the costs of handling cash for a retailer i.e. staff time to count it and to reconcile cash tills, staff time to deposit cash at a bank branch, associated bank fees for cash deposits levied by some institutions, lost cash interest on cash float amounts equates to much more than the actual card processing costs. 

I very much doubt whether the above costs are factored into any analysis conducted by any self-serving retailer group.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Russell Bell
Russell Bell - Fastbase Ltd - Wellington | 03 June, 2014, 05:26

Your typical retail business owner isn't ignorant of the costs of different payment methods.  But they don't turn away customers who've only cash in their pocket or only plastic.  They'll deal with whatever costs and issues arise, with whatever payment methods their customers want to use.  It's natural they resent high transaction fees.  Especially on low-margin sales.

Credit card charge-backs are another spanner in the works.  Often the business wants to offer lower prices for website sales.  That's ok for sales on-account where you build a relationship with the customer and trust them to pay later.

But for casual website sales both parties want instant gratification, payment right now.  Not so easy when over the web you can only accept payment via credit card or PayPal and both are subject to charge-backs.  How do you set prices when you can't predict how often payments to you will get reversed, for no fault of your own ?

4 thumb ups! 4 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Paul Davidson
Paul Davidson - Expense Reduction Analysts - London | 03 June, 2014, 10:43

I agree, Russell, that retail businesses are mindful of costs, though a key challenge which we see in mid-sized retailers is accessing and interpreting the mix of transaction and card types from the data provided by acquirers.

Outside IC+ models there are so many variations which muddy the waters and make decisions on process change to avoid non-secure premium charges and comparison between acquirers very challenging.

Knowing that doesn't stop retailers feeling frustrated, in fact it's when people perceive they are facing barriers they can't overcome that they'll rail against a system.

2 thumb ups! 2 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Russell Bell
Russell Bell - Fastbase Ltd - Wellington | 03 June, 2014, 22:58

Retailers bend over backwards for their customers, competition obliges them to.  They look at the behaviour of Visa & MC and card-issuing banks and don't see a competitive payment industry bending over backwards for them.  The banks make handsome profits on these interchange fees.  Such extraordinary profits you won't see in a healthy market.

For sure analysis of transaction data might help a retailer, not an easy task when the fee pricing is so complex and opaque.  And there's Durbin et-al on the regulatory front.  But that's just detail, the big picture is not healthy.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Finextra news in your inbox

For Finextra's free daily newsletter, breaking news flashes and weekly jobs board: sign up now

Related stories

Cash is here to stay says US Federal Reserve

Cash is here to stay says US Federal Reserve

30 April 2014  |  7102 views  |  5 comments | 12 tweets | 7 linkedin
Cash usage on the wane - Halifax

Cash usage on the wane - Halifax

29 April 2014  |  5340 views  |  0 comments | 8 tweets | 5 linkedin
London buses to scrap cash fares

London buses to scrap cash fares

03 February 2014  |  10515 views  |  4 comments | 11 tweets | 19 linkedin
Whither the cashless society? UK ATM withdrawals to top £11 billion in December

Whither the cashless society? UK ATM withdrawals to top £11 billion in December

04 December 2013  |  6814 views  |  3 comments | 11 tweets | 14 linkedin
Sweden's homeless turn to mPOS as cash payments dry up

Sweden's homeless turn to mPOS as cash payments dry up

18 October 2013  |  9126 views  |  1 comments | 11 tweets | 13 linkedin
Increasing demand for cash boosts global ATM market

Increasing demand for cash boosts global ATM market

30 September 2013  |  8106 views  |  1 comments | 12 tweets | 13 linkedin
Global non-cash payments soar to 333 billion in 2012

Global non-cash payments soar to 333 billion in 2012

16 September 2013  |  9645 views  |  0 comments | 9 tweets | 14 linkedin
Payments in 2022: Cash out, mobile in

Payments in 2022: Cash out, mobile in

19 August 2013  |  15651 views  |  7 comments | 29 tweets | 17 linkedin
Dutch central bank comes down in favour of hard cash

Dutch central bank comes down in favour of hard cash

28 June 2013  |  9073 views  |  3 comments | 12 tweets | 9 linkedin
Cash costs the German economy EUR12.5 billion per year

Cash costs the German economy EUR12.5 billion per year

13 June 2013  |  8411 views  |  3 comments | 8 tweets | 8 linkedin
Cash use in the UK on the rise

Cash use in the UK on the rise

10 June 2013  |  10015 views  |  1 comments | 15 tweets | 6 linkedin
Show me the money: Cash usage forecast to continue growing for another decade

Show me the money: Cash usage forecast to continue growing for another decade

04 June 2013  |  9217 views  |  0 comments | 15 tweets | 9 linkedin
Brits turn away from cash as digital alternatives gain currency

Brits turn away from cash as digital alternatives gain currency

30 May 2013  |  5968 views  |  1 comments | 13 tweets | 12 linkedin
All hail King Coin!

All hail King Coin!

19 April 2013  |  7020 views  |  0 comments | 7 tweets

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)
http://www.financialcrimerisk.fiserv.com/aml?r=finextraVisit capgemini.comVisit aciworldwide.com

Top topics

Most viewed Most shared
China tops world fintech rankingsChina tops world fintech rankings
8492 views comments | 39 tweets | 31 linkedin
EBA bends under weight of PSD2 mandatesEBA bends under weight of PSD2 mandates
8078 views comments | 37 tweets | 48 linkedin
Guesswork alone can crack Visa card security - Newcastle UniversityGuesswork alone can crack Visa card securi...
7979 views 12 comments | 15 tweets | 27 linkedin
PSD2 will transform the payments landscapePSD2 will transform the payments landscape
6994 views comments | 23 tweets | 13 linkedin
Fed Governor sounds warning on alternative credit scoring dataFed Governor sounds warning on alternative...
6822 views comments | 20 tweets | 23 linkedin

Featured job

to Six-Figure Base, Bonus, Benefits
London, UK

Find your next job