21 November 2017
Philippe Carrel

Philippe Carrel

Philippe Carrel - Young Bankers Connect

10Posts 36,255Views 2Comments


26 January 2014  |  3544 views  |  0

Why Bitcoin is not a currency and why can't it be one just yet? It's because a currency is more than a medium of exchange. A currency represents a value (in equivalent labour or means of subsistence) under a given set of economic and political conditions, including and most importantly, enough power to defend such value. The first forms of currencies were receipts representing grains stored in temples in Mesopotamia. Their value largely depended on the strength of the armies defending them. 

Such is the fundamental role of a currency, to represent the value produced by its holders. If only a cross-border mean of exchange, you might as well use salt. Bitcoin lacks the collateral value provided by a king, a central bank, or even a large commercial bank, or any form of authority ready to stand and defend it as if it were in Fort Knox. 

One should not confuse virtual currency with dematerialised means of payments. All currencies including the US Dollar are virtual -not because we use credit cards instead of notes but since the gold standard was abandonned. Ever since, the value of currencies has depended on the credibility of governments to roll over their debts into new ones. Thus the mere collateral they are left with is their sovereign credit rating. 

This is not to say that only central banks can create currencies. The Hong Kong Dollar was once issued by commercial banks. The Euro is not a basket, hence quite virtual too. Whether it is a bank, a fund or a consortium, some economic or political power must stand for the value represented by a currency. When it fails to do so, then the currency turns worthless, or actually comes back to the value of its physical support, copper, nickel or paper. From the Weimach Republic to Zimbabwee, countless tales of abandonned currencies prove that value depends on a perceived balance of collateral and power.

Where does this leave Bitcoin? In recent years, the G7 took their currencies on a rough path, with quantitative easing, political deficiencies and excessive debt. Doing so, they damaged the "credibility collateral" of their currencies, thus increasing their virtual value. As a result, gold sky-rocketted and an alternative virtual initiative such as Bitcoin could emerge. Both gold and Bitcoin have no central bank, no king, no country. Both can be mined by those who know where and how to find it. Both are rare, theoretically unlimited in volume and bear a cost to warehouse. But unlike gold, Bitcoin is not material, hence can't be used to rebalance the lost credibility of the other virtual currencies. Unlike gold, there is little reserve disclosure. 

Unless a sovereign fund, a central bank or a regulated private institution offers a robust balance sheet as collateral for Bitcoin and discloses holdings to prove its credibility, then the value of Bitcoin will remain purely virtual. As such it merely depends on the day to day demand, a derivative of media coverage. Will it blossom as Dutch tulips?


TagsBlockchainTrade executionRisk & regulation

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Philippe


26 January 2014  |  3544 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsBlockchainTrade executionRisk & regulation

Basel III, the new rules

14 November 2011  |  3958 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulationPost-trade & ops


20 May 2010  |  3208 views  |  2 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulation


16 May 2010  |  9873 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulation

New Euro Order: The Empire Strikes Back

11 May 2010  |  2913 views  |  1 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulation

Philippe's profile

job title Founder
location Geneva
member since 2008
Summary profile See full profile »
The Charter of the Young Bankers defines the financial industry as a creator of wealth and welfare. Joining the association is to join the global Endeavour that forever changes the way financial insti...

Philippe's expertise

Member since 2007
10 posts2 comments
What Philippe reads
Handbook of Risk Management
Philippe's blog archive
2014 (1)2011 (1)2010 (3)2008 (5)

Who's commenting on Philippe's posts