23 October 2017
Brendan Doyle

Brendan Doyle

Brendan Doyle - CMS

7Posts 25,857Views 6Comments

Open Letter to the Bank of England: Concerns over Polymer

24 January 2014  |  3105 views  |  0

In December 2014, the Bank of England made a decision to introduce Polymer Banknotes into circulation, starting with the £5 notes in 2016 and the £10 note in 2017.

On behalf of Cash Management Solutions, I have voiced my concerns in an open letter to the Bank of England:




Dear [Name supplied if requested],

I am writing to put some questions to you about the process the Bank of England has followed regarding the introduction of Polymer notes and to tell you that I would like to see an independent review of this decision.

I had understood that the Bank would engage all stakeholders in the process and that a key element of the decision making process was to be an analysis of the costs of the change-over to the private sector. I was, therefore, very surprised to see that a decision was announced within days of the Christmas holiday with no reference to the cost benefit analysis having been completed. Indeed, no mention was made of any of the concerns I raised during the consultation process. Given the position we are now in, I have asked that the matter be raised with HM Treasury as I believe that an independent review of the decision is necessary.

My concerns are as follows;

  1. As the Bank of England stands to gain financially from the changeover, the consultation process should have been conducted independently with a remit to undertake a cost benefit analysis for the whole economy. 
  2. Given that we are still not aware of the costs of introduction, I am concerned that the consultation may not have been thorough & transparent. 
  3. As it is, the decision may involve a significant transfer of costs from the public sector to the private sector. 
  4. That this decision may be consistent with a number of decisions by the Bank of England, over a long period of time, that have increased barriers to entry in the cash processing industry, resulting in higher long term costs for consumers and businesses. 
  5. That a number of businesses, especially smaller ones, associated with cash provision, may suffer disproportionately from this decision. 
  6. Conversely, a number of businesses, especially larger ones, may gain financial & commercial benefits from this decision at the expense of smaller rivals. 

It would be good to understand the Bank's position on the above points, as I would like to know whether or not they have been considered and the importance given to each in the process.

Brendan Doyle
CEO, Cash Management Solutions




I have also published the message on our website at www.cashmanagement.co.uk/news-and-events/open-letter-to-bank-of-england/. If anyone reading this would like to speak to me about these issues, please feel free to get in contact.

TagsPaymentsRisk & regulation

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Brendan

Cash Office Technology: Time to Consider the Business Case

18 April 2016  |  4241 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRetail bankingTransaction banking

Cash is under threat. Those who don't agree need to pull their head out the sand.

10 April 2015  |  1979 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsPaymentsRetail banking

Prepare Now For Interest Rate Rises or Suffer Later

19 June 2014  |  2910 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsCardsRetail banking

ATM Cash Management: Prepare now for rises in interest rates

02 June 2014  |  3977 views  |  1 comments | recomends Recommends 2 TagsPaymentsRetail banking

Why we need to question the BoE's whimsical polymer decision

27 February 2014  |  4615 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsPaymentsRetail banking

Brendan's profile

job title CEO
location Manchester
member since 2013
Summary profile See full profile »

Brendan's expertise

Member since 2013
7 posts6 comments
What Brendan reads
Brendan's blog archive
2016 (1)2015 (1)2014 (4)2013 (1)

Who's commenting on Brendan's posts