26 April 2018
Amit Agrawal


Amit Agrawal - AxiomSL Pte Ltd

12Posts 37,966Views 3Comments
Financial Risk Management

Financial Risk Management

This network brings together professionals involved in the oversight and management of their company's financial risks and exposures as well as solution vendors, in order to discuss risk issues including interest rate risk, foreign exchange risk and commodity price risk, among others.

Why do RWA differ across countries

23 January 2014  |  4402 views  |  0

Risk Weights Assets (RWA) allocate an amount of capital to the assets held by a financial institution as a function of their risk perception and the origination nature (the higher the perceived risk, the higher the risk weight). RWA are core input in the calculation of a financial institution capital ratio and were first introduced in Basel I
Anyways, under Basel III  RWA is changed to capture market risk and counter party related risks which was not available in Basel II. Also Basel III stresses the integration between liquidity and credit risk which need to manage from an enterprise wide context and hence banks need to have enterprise wide capital ratio calculation framework and reporting infrastructure. It means banks need to focus on maximizing the capital ratio which is heavily dependent on RWAs. 
Numerous studies have expressed concerns about the consistency of RWA calculation, specifically concerning its reliability and accuracy of capital ratio, its lack of cyclicality and its usage as an indicator to measure balance sheet.  It is observed that the differences between the average RWA/TA ratios (“RWA density”) across regions are significant, prompting questions about consistency across the RWA methodologies used by banks in different jurisdictions , and casting doubts on the reliability of banks’ capital ratios. For example : RWA density is different across North America, Europe and Asian institutions.  European banks have, on average the lowest RWA density versus Asian and North American institutions (36%, 50%, and 58% respectively).  The below are some of the factors influencing RWA :

  • Regulatory Framework
  • Supervisory Framework
  • Accounting Framework
  • Legal Framework
  • Economic Cycle
  • Business Model

I do understand that we would expect some degree of RWA differences to remain. This would reflect bank's different business models and risk profiles, but also account for different views on risks among regulators. Some variations among estimates of RWAs for similar risks may be acceptable and contribute to financial stability, through the co-existence of different business choices, models and risk appetites. A uniform risk measurement might lead to herd behavior and be detrimental to some asset classes (reduction in exposures), while others could become over-crowded. 

The main aim of reforming RWAs is not to seek a full harmonization, but to ensure a greater level of consistency in methodologies and higher transparency in the outputs, for banks and their supervisors.


Disclosure : I wrote this article myself and it express my own opinion

TagsRisk & regulationWholesale banking

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Amit

Risk Ratios

22 November 2014  |  3073 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulationPost-trade & opsGroupFinancial Services Regulation

Local compliance in a global business

13 September 2014  |  2810 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulationSibosGroupFinancial Services Regulation

Intraday Liquidity: Implement Challenges

12 June 2014  |  2991 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulationWholesale bankingGroupFinancial Services Regulation

Non Compliance Cost

10 May 2014  |  2235 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsRisk & regulationInnovationGroupFinancial Services Regulation

Hidden Cost of Compliance

04 March 2014  |  2197 views  |  1 comments | recomends Recommends 1 TagsRisk & regulationPost-trade & opsGroupFinancial Services Regulation

Amit's profile

job title Vice President
location Singapore
member since 2010
Summary profile See full profile »
Managing engagements to automate entire business process to automate risk calculations like liquidity, Basel and compliance reports for multiple jurisdictions like Korea, India etc

Amit's expertise

Member since 2010
12 posts3 comments
What Amit reads
Amit's blog archive
2014 (6)2013 (6)

Who's commenting on Amit's posts