17 January 2018
Chris Dunne

Chris Dunne

Chris Dunne - VocaLink Limited

21Posts 86,178Views 14Comments
Finextra community

Payments strategies 2015-2020-2030

Payments systems visions, strategies, trends, pilots, forecasting, and planning for the short-, medium-, and far-term.

All change for retail banking in the UK

20 November 2012  |  4022 views  |  2

The Parliamentary Commission on Banking Standards has been a hive of activity recently, gathering evidence from the chief executives of UK banks as well as key thinkers such as Sir John Vickers, who chaired the Independent Commission on Banking, and Andy Haldane from the Bank of England.

The Commission is composed of a formidable array of talent from both houses of parliament, including the Lord Bishop of Durham (who has just won a rapid promotion to be the next Archbishop of Canterbury), Lord Lawson, Andrew Tyrie MP, Baroness Kramer and Mark Garnier MP.

The Commission is working hard to deliver its findings by mid-December to guide the debate on the Banking Reform Bill, which is set to transform the banking sector in the UK.  The stakes are high on both sides and the sessions have been closely watched across the industry.

We were fortunate to have Mark Garnier MP speaking at one of our Payment Dinners recently to give us an insight into the workings of the commission and his personal views on how the industry needs to change.  This was not an exercise in banker bashing; he made it clear that banks perform a socially useful service.  He said that if money is the oil in the engine of the economy then banks are the pump pushing that oil to where it is needed, adding that they are the most efficient distributor of money from where it has accumulated to where it is needed.

Mark discussed the relative merits of different approaches to ring fencing proposed by Vickers, Volker, Kay and Liikanen.  I can’t do the discussion justice in a short blog, but it was neatly encapsulated by the question: do we put a fence around the deer park (Vickers), or do we cage the tigers (Liikanen)?  There is no simple answer but all agree that the current status quo can’t be maintained.

The discussion naturally turned towards competition, in particular the low level of current account switching; it’s about 2% a year.  Mark explained that he had recently moved bank accounts and it had been “six weeks of hell and confusion”.  His view is that account portability is vital not just to introduce competition to the market but also to aid resolution of failing banks. 

I have to declare an interest here – we are developing the central infrastructure for the enhanced current account switching service on behalf of the Payments Council.    This will deliver a greatly improved switching service in September 2013, and there is enormous focus across the industry to land  this programme on time. 

Mark’s view that we should just jump straight to account portability is one that I’ve heard from several senior figures and I think it reflects frustration with the current low levels of customer movement.  The countervailing view is that most of the benefits of portability will be delivered by the new switching service, and so the incremental benefits of portability will be dwarfed by the potential costs.

So at the moment there is no agreed way forward on ring fencing or portability, but one thing is certain – retail banking in the UK is heading into a period of unprecedented change.

TagsRetail bankingTransaction banking

Comments: (2)

A Finextra member
A Finextra member | 20 November, 2012, 12:21

I really dont think its a technology issue more about raising understanding and awareness of the consumer. For many apathy is the major problem. Prepared to grumble asnd moan but take no action. The banks will hardly market portability so who will?

For portability to work there has to be a massive increase in showing the consumer that its worthwhile and not just as a knee jerk reaction to some banking failure to supply a service. This apathy is the main reason why consumers  prefer to sit moaning and this should be the main focus of attack. The technology will then be used

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Mark Pavan
Mark Pavan - Mapa research - London | 21 November, 2012, 18:27

Interesting post and very broad sweeps. If I may let us look only at Retail Banking and stick to the UK.

I think the problem here is the misnomer of the ingrained perception of "free banking" that came when Girobank's current account offer went mainstream back in the 1990 and has, due as much to politicians as the banks themselves,come to be the value placed on banking by consumers.Zero. Free means nothing. Therefore current accounts by themselves are not profitable: hence all the other banking nonsense. Misselling, packaged accounts,account compulsions etc that have come out.

Let banks charge and make money overtly: then better accounts will follow.

This is just a crumble in a huge pie and there are a zillion other viewpoints but just this to start.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)

Latest posts from Chris

Faster Payments takes off for small business

16 September 2014  |  3165 views  |  3 comments | recomends Recommends 1 TagsMobile & onlinePayments

Mobile services strengthen customers’ bond with banks

09 July 2014  |  3673 views  |  5 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsMobile & onlinePaymentsGroupInnovation in Financial Services

Labour’s three objectives for banking reform

09 May 2014  |  3067 views  |  0 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsPaymentsRetail bankingGroupInnovation in Financial Services

PaySwarm: the most disruptive innovation in payments

19 September 2013  |  6168 views  |  1 comments | recomends Recommends 0 TagsPaymentsSibosGroupInnovation in Financial Services

Chris's profile

job title Payment Services Director
location London
member since 2012
Summary profile See full profile »
Responsible for the Bacs and Faster Payments scheme businesses and the relationships with the Bank of England, HM Treasury, Payments Council, FCA, BBA and SWIFT. Also responsible for Government busin...

Chris's expertise

Member since 2004
21 posts14 comments
What Chris reads
Chris's blog archive
2014 (4)2013 (12)2012 (5)

Who's commenting on Chris's posts