24 May 2013

Flash crash reforms will fail to make markets safer - study

18 October 2012  |  4461 views  |  1 Risk

The new circuit breaker system designed to avoid a repeat of 2010's flash crash will fail to avert another market meltdown unless it is coupled with 'liquidity safety valves', warns a new piece of academic research.

Responding to the May 2010 flash crash, which sent the S&P 500 index plummeting in minutes, the SEC initially introduced circuit breakers which pause trading in stocks if their prices change by more than 10% in five minutes.

Next year these will be replaced with a 'limit up-limit down' mechanism, where trades in listed stocks will have to be executed within a range tied to recent prices for that security.

But researchers from London's Cass Business School and the HEC School of Management in Paris argue that the limit up-limit down system will not be enough to prevent another rout because the advent of high frequency trading has led to markets becoming progressively intertwined.

Co-author Giovanni Cespa says: "This liquidity evaporation may materialise in one market first, triggering a spiral that drags all assets into the illiquid regime. Price based circuit breakers do not necessarily offer a good protection against such illiquidity spirals because the latter may happen without trades and therefore without changes in prices."

To counter this risk, Cespa and co-author Thierry Foucault call for new 'illiquidity-based circuit breakers' in tandem with price-based ones. This would mean trading could be stopped when market-wide depth falls below a specified threshold.

"It could be an effective way to block an illiquidity spiral at its inception and thereby help traders to re-coordinate on a regime with higher liquidity," adds Cespa.

Comments: (1)

Comment on this story (membership required)
Gary Wright - BISS Research - London | 18 October, 2012, 09:50

I have to agree with this conclusion.My fear is liquidity failings will prove the most serious risk as markets fragment and build pressures undetected until too late.One failing of a market would quickly pass from one too the other.The solution is to look at a combination of responces to market problems that do not create a move round of risk affecting all in due course

Log in to receive notifications when someone posts a comment

Related blogs

Create a blog about this story (membership required)

Related stories

05 October, 2012
27 July, 2011
06 April, 2011
18 February, 2011
12 August, 2010
30 June, 2010
19 May, 2010
12 May, 2010
Find out moreFind out more

Who is commenting?

Finextra Member Commented on: 'Hello. I'm on Mount E...
Brett King Commented on: The Naked King
Brett King Commented on: The Naked King

Featured job

Excellent salary with uncapped commission
Milton Keynes

Find your next job