06 February 2016

44975

Retired Member

1,364Posts 4,705,319Views 1,604Comments

Hitting the bullseye

02 December 2013  |  3107 views  |  0

According to recent press articles, the MiFID II trilogue has agreed on capping dark trading at an arbitrary 4% per venue and 8% overall market share. At the heart of the discussion around dark trading lies the role of transparency in the wider market. While one side claims that transparency is the only thing that can keep fragmented markets efficient, the other side worries about the undue restriction of legitimate and long-standing business practices. Whichever way you look at it, the new rules stand little chance of making either side happy.

Firstly, the thresholds of 4% and 8% seem fairly random, with little empirical evidence to back them up. As Markus Ferber pointed out: “This is an area where no one has any experience because no data is available. It is not that easy to agree on a volume cap if you don’t really know what’s going on.” And if we can’t measure things now, how are we going to measure them in the future?

These thresholds will be written into the Level 1 text. Given that it took European legislators about ten years to review MiFID I and agree on MiFID II, it seems strange that they could so quickly move to set their guestimates in stone for the next decade. Why legislators can’t simply leave it to ESMA to come up with sensible thresholds, specific to instruments or instrument groups, remains a mystery.

Let’s hope that the trilogue hits the bullseye when it comes to dark pool thresholds. Otherwise, we might find ourselves wishing for MiFID III even before MiFID II is fully implemented.

 

TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)
Log in to receive notifications when someone posts a comment

Latest posts from

Retired's profile

job title
location
member since 2014
Summary profile See full profile »

Retired's expertise

What Retired reads
Retired writes about

Who's commenting on Retired's posts

Steve Patel
Aparty Behera
Ketharaman Swaminathan
Karim Maalouf
Brendan Burge
Konstantin Rabin
Paul Zaman
Astrid Mitchell
Balasubramaniam GD
Graham Seel
Bjorn Soland
Miloslav Hoschek