22 May 2015

Fidessa Fragmentation Index

Steve Grob - Fidessa

105Posts 329,780Views 3Comments

NYSE DB - why Brussels got it wrong

03 February 2012  |  2806 views  |  0

Not much surprise at this week’s news then, but the rationale for blocking the deal seems odd. Firstly, and whatever they may claim, Brussels did take an overly Eurocentric view. Just call the CME in Chicago and ask where Liffe and Eurex appear on its list of major competitors. Secondly, the Commission claims that LIFFE and EUREX themselves compete but, in fact, they are effectively two ‘mini-monopolies’ operating at opposite ends of the yield curve with almost zero overlap in their products. So it’s not as if the competitive landscape for European derivatives was particularly vibrant anyway. But the biggest issue concerns how the Commission calculated the potential market share for the combined entity. How could they exclude OTC derivatives in their sums when just along the corridor they are also introducing regulation aimed at pushing the OTC and exchange-traded worlds together?

That is not to say that the decision was necessarily wrong, but the reasoning behind it doesn’t seem to stack up. As one of our previous polls showed, the market was pretty evenly divided on the issue but with a significant number of “don’t knows”.

For these swing voters, maybe it’s all about capital efficiency. Ever since the financial crisis, capital has become an increasingly valuable commodity as market regulators around the world are steadily upping the requirements. Would a combined entity have been able to offer more efficient use of capital through margin offsets or otherwise netting positions for traders? Or, would a combined entity have been able to drive up prices and exploit its position without exchanges like the CME or NASDAQ  jumping in?

Personally, I think Brussels might end up adding this decision to the “Not sure we got it right” pile.

TagsDealing roomsTrade execution

Comments: (0)

Comment on this story (membership required)
Log in to receive notifications when someone posts a comment

Latest posts from Steve

Having your regulatory cake and eating it

14 May 2015  |  1755 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Backdoor Unbundling

09 April 2015  |  4747 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

GMEX - going to eleven?

19 February 2015  |  4196 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade execution

Why the Daleks and Vogons were right about financial markets

08 January 2015  |  4278 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Last minute shopping in Europe

05 December 2014  |  2722 views  |  1  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Steve's profile

job title Director of Group Strategy
location London
member since 2009
Summary profile See full profile »
I am responsible for strategic development at Fidessa. This includes the development of new geographic markets and strategic partnerships and driving new industry initiatives. As part of this I head u...

Steve's expertise

What Steve reads
Steve writes about

Who's commenting on Steve's posts

Andrew Miller