28 May 2015

44975

Retired Member

905Posts 2,937,474Views 1,191Comments

Financial Risk Management

This network brings together professionals involved in the oversight and management of their company's financial risks and exposures as well as solution vendors, in order to discuss risk issues including interest rate risk, foreign exchange risk and commodity price risk, among others.

What if banks were really fined based on income?

20 August 2010  |  5188 views  |  1

Thanks to Ian Wigman for this gem from WIRED magazine.  A man in Switzerland was recently fined a record $290,000 for driving 85 mph in a 50 mph limit. (It was less before he pleaded his case!)  The reason being in 2002 the Swiss replaced prison sentences for some offenses, with fines based on income. The driver in question has a reputed income of $820,000 and so in the end they took 35% of it as the penalty.

In a recent article in the Guardian they reported on the £5.6m fine issued to RBS but also included the top 10 fines dished out by the FSA since February 2010, totalling nearly £55m.

This got me thinking, what if Banking Regulators decided to apply the same logic and percentages as the Swiss courts?!

I haven't done the maths but I am sure the fines would have totalled a hell of a lot more than £55m.

Just looking generally at fines metered out in recent times and not just by the FSA, a good number seem to be a result of:

    * internal processes not being transparent
    * failure to follow published regulations
    * inadequate controls to monitor compliance to same
    * poorly defined accountability

Can you see the cause and effect here?  That's a theme Ian will be presenting about in London (22-23 Sept) and Houston (19-20 October) at "Inspiring Performance" conferences.  As Ian will be making clear; it's a lot easier for companies to comply with the basic "rules of the road" if they obtain business process transparency first.

To round-off the driving analogy - the alternative might be compared to rush hour commuting with your windscreen misted-up - quite scary and potentially fatal.

With the FSA being "wound-up" in the not too distant future, we might presume that they want to go out on a high.  There has been talk of linking fines to company income.  Let's hope they don't ask the Swiss police for advice.

Blog updated: 26 May 2015 18:19:29
Transparency? TagsRisk & regulationSibos

Comments: (1)

Keith Appleyard - available for hire - Bromley | 23 August, 2010, 11:12

reading the original Swiss article, as I suspected the amounts were in Swiss Francs not US Dollars - I think the Wired correspondent just couldn't cope with doing a currency conversion.

Be the first to give this comment the thumbs up 0 thumb ups! (Log in to thumb up)
Comment on this story (membership required)
Log in to receive notifications when someone posts a comment

Latest posts from Retired

Banking on biometrics

17 May 2015  |  1514 views  |  1  |  Recommends 0 TagsSecurityInnovation

Flagging on the road to transparency

27 April 2015  |  3235 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Left in the dark

26 March 2015  |  2754 views  |  0  |  Recommends 1 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Holding a steady course

12 March 2015  |  2624 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsTrade executionRisk & regulation

Analysis dialysis

24 February 2015  |  1589 views  |  0  |  Recommends 0 TagsRetail bankingInnovation

Retired's profile

job title
location
member since 2014
Summary profile See full profile »

Retired's expertise

What Retired reads
Retired writes about

Who's commenting on Retired's posts

Noel Peatfield
Karim Maalouf
Ketharaman Swaminathan
Sreeram Yegappan
AMIT GARG
Tony Wenzel
Melvin Haskins